Free Insurance Comparison

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Laura Berry

Former Insurance Agent

Former Insurance Agent

Joshua Adamson

Joshua is a copywriter at Obrella who for more than 10 years has been creating content about insurance, health care, and more. He helps companies explain complex insurance subjects in simple ways so that customers can make smart buying decisions. He spends way too much time binge-watching Netflix, loves the outdoors and has a cat who tolerates him.

UPDATED: Jul 14, 2021

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.

Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything legal and insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by experts.

We’ve done the research to find everything you need to know from average premiums by insurance company to the most popular ones. If you drink “caw-fee,” harbor a healthy Red Sox rivalry, and have some of the best pizza around, this car insurance page is most certainly for you New York drivers.

What Are You Looking For?

Where Can You Find New York’s Cheapest Auto Policies?

There are 172 insurance companies in New York. We decided to take an in-depth look at seven companies and calculate average annual car insurance premiums based on 10 cities and eight driver profiles. See how much car insurance company rates fluctuate by checking out the cheapest options below.

New York's Cheapest Car InsuranceAverage Annual Rates
New York Central Mutual$1,004.97
Liberty Mutual$2,138.97

Compare RatesStart Now →

*These premiums were calculated by using driver profiles of people with a 2013 Honda Civic LX (4-door), good credit, no accidents, and 50/100/110 coverage.

Of course, these results can vary widely based on a bunch of little things including credit score, driving record, and which discounts you take advantage of. A clean driving record is just one part of insurance pricing. When it comes to cheap car insurance, getting your own quotes is crucial.

How Much Drivers Like You Spend On Auto Insurance

Every driver is unique. Check out our more specific rates for different driver profiles below so you can find rates that might more closely match your own life.

Cheapest For Drivers 25 And Under

Based on the 18 and 25-year old driver profiles we ran number for, we were able to find the cheapest car insurance companies in New York for this age group. Take a look.

New York's Cheapest Car InsuranceAverage Annual Rates
New York Central Mutual$1,110.00
Liberty Mutual$2,958.50

Compare RatesStart Now →

Rates For 25-Year Old Men Vs Women

Men pay about 10% more than women for car insurance. Chubb is the only exception—women will pay 2% more with them. But as you can see, here’s how our cheapest auto insurance calculations break down for young male and female drivers.


Cheapest For Gen X Drivers

Based on profiles of married men and women who are 40-years old, our data pointed out that the cheapest auto insurance companies for your age group as are follows:

Average Annual Rates
New York Central Mutual$987.20
Liberty Mutual$1,400.10

Compare RatesStart Now →

How Does Your City Affect Average Rates?

From Binghamton to the Big Apple, you’ll find different car insurance rates. Auto insurance companies use thousands and millions of data points to calculate risk and that’s why it varies so much. Crime rates, traffic patterns, and the likelihood of different kinds of claims all play into your rates. Even if you have a clean driving record, you’re still a higher risk if you live in an area that has a lot of accidents, break-ins, etc. Binghamton is the cheapest for auto coverage, but take a look to see how your city measures up based on our data.

CityAverage Annual Rates
West Seneca$1,232.58
Long Beach$1,282.72
Niagra Falls$1,365.70
New Rochelle$1,389.41
White Plains$1,710.85
West Seneca$2,044.00
Mount Vernon$2,098.72
New York City$2,133.60

Compare RatesStart Now →

Who Is The Most Popular New York Car Insurance Provider?

Market share is something that shows how many customers a company has compared to competitors. Based on our analysis, Geico is New York’s most popular auto insurance provider with nearly one third of all insured drivers on their policies. Looking at this kind of data can show you where the most customers are going and give you an idea how well liked certain companies are.

The most popular company isn’t always the cheapest car insurance company. Insurance companies have to cater to a range of preferences to get the highest market share. Insurance cost is a small part of the bigger picture.

New York's Cheapest Car InsuranceAverage Annual Rates
New York Central Mutual$1,004.97
Liberty Mutual$2,138.97

Compare RatesStart Now →

What Is Our Recommendation?

We want you to use our data and analysis to make the best car insurance decision for you. Just keep in mind that you should always choose a carrier that ranks well across multiple categories. According to our research, Geico ranked number one for New York auto insurance market share and second for cheapest rates. Going with a company like that that has great scoring overall will help you find better coverage.

If you’re not sure what to do, give a licensed agent a call. They’re very experienced in New York auto coverage and insurance as a whole.

Where We Found The Facts

All of the premiums above were calculated using driver profiles of people who have a 2013 Honda Civic LX (4-door), good credit, no accidents, and 50/100/110 coverage. While those numbers are real, they might not be what you’ll pay as a policyholder if your personal details are any different. We just wanted to be able to show you what average drivers pay so you have a better understanding of the prices out there.

Source Links:


Free Insurance Comparison

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption